# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- # Differences with VizieR catalog J_A+A_530_A93 (Secunda and Tertia classis) # ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- - Numbering differences KNO 1006 \ are their K1005 due to star set differences in Tycho KNO 1097 / to K1096 KNO 1098 : is their K1096 alternative in altiter.dat KNO 1099 \ are their K1997 KNO 1440 / to K1438 (including 3a classis) TID Sgr 17 : is their Sgr 30 TID Sgr 18 : is their alternative version of Sgr 30 TID Sgr 19 : is their Sgr 31 TID Sgr 20 \ are their Sgr 15 TID Sgr 34 / to Sgr 29 - Data differences J/A+A/530/A93 |Mine |Description ----+------+----------+--------+--+----+------+----------+--------+--+------------------------- K cst N LON LAT M |KNO TID LON LAT M | ----+------+----------+--------+--+----+------+----------+--------+--+------------------------- 1024 Oph 50 6 |1025 Oph 50 4 | 1036 Oph 62 ne|1037 Oph 62 - |mag. 9 should be 8 1064 Tau 52 2 |1065 Tau 52 1 |documented emendation >1098 Sgr 18 8 25 40 -06 50 3 |as 1096 Sgr 30 in aliter 1139 Eri 32 1 |1141 Eri 32 0 |documented emendation 1140 Eri 33 1 |1142 Eri 33 0 |documented emendation ----+------+----------+--------+--+----+------+----------+--------+--+------------------------- 1339 Ind 9 ne|1341 Ind 9 6 |mag. 9 should be 6 1408 Dor 6 ne|1410 Dor 6 - |mag. 9 should be 8 1433 Hyi 16 ne|1435 Hyi 16 - |mag. 9 should be 8 ----+------+----------+--------+--+----+------+----------+--------+--+------------------------- - Differences in the assignments of Ptolemy numbers The following list shows the differences between their assignments of Ptolemy numbers (column PNO*) and mine (column PNO) along with a short comment. KNO TID PNO PNO* Comment ----+------+-+----+----+----------------------------------------------------- 1007 Boo 29 = 97 91 typo? 1010 Her 31 = 148 0 but positions match 1051 Ser 26 = 274 0 but positions match w/ Ptolemy (b) 1057 Tau 44 = 409 0 interpretation of "advance side" of the Pleiades 1062 Tau 49 x 409 interpretation of "advance side" of the Pleiades 1098 Sgr 18 = 570 not in V&V 1154 CMa 19 = 836 0 but positions match 1192 Nav 39 = 879 0 assuming gross position error in Kepler 1193 Nav 40 = 880 0 assuming gross position error in Kepler 1194 Nav 41 = 881 0 assuming gross position error in Kepler 1230 Cen 19 = 953 954 but positions match 1231 Cen 20 = 954 0 but positions match w/ Ptolemy (m) 1234 Cen 23 = 957 958 but positions match 1235 Cen 24 = 958 959 but positions match w/ Ptolemy (m) 1236 Cen 25 = 959 0 assuming latitude error in Kepler 1246 Cen 35 = 969 957 assuming gross longitude error in Kepler 1260 Lup 12 = 983 0 but positions match w/ Ptolemy (b) ----+------+-+----+----+-----------------------------------------------------